Connect with us

Published

on

Advertisement

The U.S. Supreme Court rejected a challenge to Obamacare on Thursday in California v. Texas on technical grounds, holding 7-2 that the plaintiffs — some 17 Republican-led states — lacked the standing to bring a suit against the law.
The states wanted the courts to overturn Obamacare, arguing that since the “individual mandate” penalty for not buying health insurance — which the Court, controversially, redefined as a “tax” in 2012 — had been set to zero by President Donald Trump’s tax reforms, the entire law was unconstitutional. Moreover, since the “individual mandate” was integral to the functioning of Obamacare, it could not be severed from the law, and therefore the whole law had to be discarded.

In a majority opinion written by Justice Stephen Breyer, the Court held:

The Constitution gives federal courts the power to adjudicate only genuine “Cases” and “Controversies.” Art. III, §2. To have standing, a plaintiff must “allege personal injury fairly traceable to the defendant’s allegedly unlawful conduct and likely to be redressed by the requested relief.” DaimlerChrysler Corp. v. Cuno, 547 U. S. 332, 342. No plaintiff has shown such an injury “fairly traceable” to the “allegedly unlawful conduct” challenged here.

Though the individual mandate is no longer enforceable, the Court held, “Unenforceable statutory language alone is not sufficient to establish standing.”
In a dissent, Justices Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch protested against the Court’s apparent bias: “Today’s decision is the third installment in our epic Affordable Care Act trilogy, and it follows the same pattern as installments one and two. In all three episodes, with the Affordable Care Act facing a serious threat, the Court has pulled off an improbable rescue.”
Alito wrote: “Texas and the other state plaintiffs have standing, and now that the “tax” imposed by the individual mandate is set at $0, the mandate cannot be sustained under the taxing power. As a result, it is clearly unconstitutional, and to the extent that the provisions of the ACA that burden the States are inextricably linked to the individual mandate, they too are unenforceable.”
Justice Clarence Thomas, in a concurring opinion, noted the double-standard of Obamacare’s defenders, “who argued in first instance that the individual coverage mandate is the Act’s linchpin, yet now, in an about-face, contend that it is just a throwaway sentence.” However, he said, the plaintiffs had not been injured by unlawful action under Obamacare in a way that would give them standing to sue, and so he cast his vote with the majority.
Breyer’s role in the majority opinion is interesting, as it comes while left-wing Democrats are insisting that he retire so that President Joe Biden can appoint a younger, liberal replacement. Justice Amy Coney Barrett, President Trump’s last appointee, joined the majority opinion; her potential ruling on the case came up during her confirmation hearing last year.

Advertisement

Advertisement
Advertisement
Comments

Supreme Court’

SCOTUS Unanimously Rules Against Illegal Aliens Seeking to Permanently Stay in U.S.

Published

on

By

Advertisement

The U.S. Supreme Court (SCOTUS) on Monday held that illegal aliens who were subsequently given Temporary Protected Status (TPS) are not eligible for green cards to permanently remain in the U.S.
Justice Elena Kagan, appointed to the court by former President Obama, wrote in a 9-0 decision that a “TPS recipient who entered the United States unlawfully is not eligible … for [lawful permanent resident] status merely by dint of his TPS.”

Jose Santos Sanchez, an illegal alien from El Salvador, came to the U.S. illegally in 1997. In 2001, Sanchez was provided TPS, a nonimmigrant status that allows him to remain in the U.S. for as long as the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) extends TPS for El Salvador.
In 2014, Sanchez applied for lawful permanent resident status, commonly known as a green card, to permanently resettle in the U.S. After the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) agency denied Sanchez’s green card application on the grounds that he first entered the U.S. illegally, Sanchez challenged the decision in a federal district court and won.
Then, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit reversed the decision, finding that because Sanchez first entered the U.S. illegally, he was not eligible for a green card under federal immigration law.

The Supreme Court held that federal immigration law “applied according to its plain terms, prevents Sanchez from becoming a [lawful permanent resident].”
“The question here is whether the conferral of TPS enables him to obtain [lawful permanent resident] status despite his unlawful entry,” Kagan writes in the Court’s opinion. “We hold that it does not.”
Kagan writes:

There is no dispute that Sanchez “entered the United States in the late 1990s unlawfully, without inspection.” But as earlier described, §1255 requires a [lawful permanent resident] applicant like Sanchez to have entered the country “lawful[ly],” with “inspection” — that is, to have been admitted. Indeed, §1255 imposes an admission requirement twice over. Its principal provision states that an applicant for [lawful permanent resident] status must have been “inspected and admitted or paroled into the United States.” [Emphasis added]
And another provision says that a person who has worked without authorization in the country — as Sanchez did for several years — may become a [lawful permanent resident] only if his presence in the United States is “pursuant to a lawful admission.” Sanchez has never claimed that he can, without aid from the TPS provision, satisfy those demands for admission. A straightforward application of §1255 thus supports the Government’s decision to deny him [lawful permanent resident] status. [Emphasis added]
And nothing in the conferral of TPS changes that result. [Emphasis added]

Advertisement

Kagan writes that while Congress “could have gone further by deeming TPS recipients to have not only nonimmigrant status but also a lawful admission,” it is not in the Court’s authority “to say that the something it does is not enough.”
“Section 1255 generally requires a lawful admission before a person can obtain [lawful permanent resident] status,” Kagan writes. “Sanchez was not lawfully admitted, and his TPS does not alter that fact. He therefore cannot become a permanent resident of this country. We affirm the judgment below.”
The ruling is the third 9-0 SCOTUS decision on immigration in the last two weeks. The Court unanimously ruled, in an opinion by Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, against a previously-deported criminal illegal alien who sought to avoid deportation.
Last week, the Court unanimously reversed, in an opinion by Justice Neil Gorsuch, a Ninth Circuit appeals court decision that helped grant immigration relief to illegal aliens seeking asylum to stay in the U.S.
The case is Sanchez v. Mayorkas, No. 20–315 in the Supreme Court of the United States.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Brittany Shepherd

‘Biden can’t wait to put a black woman on Supreme Court’…

Published

on

By

Advertisement

Race-baiting Yahoo reporter Brittany Shepherd asks whether Joe Biden plans to nominate a “black person” to the Supreme Court. Jen Psaki literally just had to remind her that there is no vacancy on the Supreme Court.

Race-baiting Yahoo reporter Brittany Shepherd asks the question.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Politics1 hour ago

NYC Candidate Sliwa: Beware the ‘Slow Creep of CRT’ into New York’s Public Schools

Politics2 hours ago

NOT A JOKE: Omar Uses New COVID Cases to Push for ‘Canceling Student Debt and Affordable Housing’

Politics3 hours ago

WATCH: Biden Mistakes Donald Trump for Barack Obama, Dismisses Moment as ‘Freudian Slip’

Politics4 hours ago

PELOSI on HOUSE MASK MANDATE: ‘Science, Science, Science, Science, and Science’

Politics5 hours ago

McCARTHY: Can Pelosi Explain the ‘Science’ in the Capitol That Changes Between the House and Senate

Politics6 hours ago

THAT WAS FAST: Seattle Mayor Calls for More Police One Year After Vowing to Defund the Department

Politics7 hours ago

DATA on ‘DEFUND’: Minnesota Sets ‘New State Records’ for Murders, Assaults on Police in 2020

Politics8 hours ago

BUMMER GAMES: Ratings for Tokyo Olympics DOWN 49% From Four Years Earlier

Politics9 hours ago

BREAKING: Texas Gov Orders National Guard to Arrest Illegal Migrants at the Southern Border

CDC11 hours ago

Trump Blasts Biden Administration For Return To Mask Mandates

Capitol breach11 hours ago

Jan. 6 hearing: Ingraham ridicules officers, give out awards to best dramatic performances

Donald Trump11 hours ago

Jan. 6 hearing: Ms. Cheney hints that Jim Jordan might be subpoena to testify

biden administration13 hours ago

Graham: Biden Admin. ‘Trying to Restrict’ Americans While Ignoring COVID Problems from Illegal Immigration

CDC13 hours ago

House of Reps enforces mask mandate after upsurge of COVID-19 cases

Capitol riot13 hours ago

CNN: January 6 Committee ‘Made It Clear They’re Going After Trump’

biden administration3 months ago

VIDEO: It’s ‘not a great time’ for America to have a ‘weak’ president: Andrew Bolt

Politics2 months ago

No Masks, No Distancing – The Disgraceful Covid Hypocrisy of the G7 Elite

Capitol Hill4 months ago

FIRST PHOTOS — Capitol Hill Killer is Black Muslim… Louis Farrakhan Supporter… Identified as 25 Year-Old Noah Green…

coronavirus4 weeks ago

Deaths from vaccine top 6K as FDA issues warning after spike in cases of fatal heart inflammation

President Trump1 month ago

Trump announces brand new 2,000-mile long luxury hotel at Southern Border…

2020 Election2 weeks ago

Arizona Audit Team Escorted from Building after Explosive Audit Hearing

Developing Story1 month ago

Arizona’s Katie Hobbs Suffers COMPLETE Meltdown on CNN – The Truth Is Coming

Nancy Pelosi4 months ago

VIDEO: FAIL: Nancy Pelosi’s Effort to Change GOP House Seat Blows Up In Her Face

2020 Election2 months ago

Sidney Powell’s bold prediction…

Candace Owens2 months ago

VIDEO: “No Escape For Pelosi, Jail Is Sure” Candace Owens Destroys Nancy Pelosi……

Dominion3 months ago

Mike Lindell Sues Dominion for $1.6 Billion

Ohio1 month ago

Watch Live: President Donald Trump Rally LIVE in Wellington, OH – 6/26/21

Whistle Blower1 month ago

Reporter Releases Undercover Video EXPOSING Media Bosses

Chicago1 month ago

HORROR In Chicago: Couple Pulled from Their Car and Shot Point Blank

Daunte Wright4 months ago

MSM will never show you this… Video of Daunte Wright waving around his gun…

Capitol Hill13 hours ago

Video: Ingraham claims Jan. 6 committee members and officers who testified merely put on a performance

Joe Biden14 hours ago

[VIDEO] HORROR! Joe, Confused, Starts Calling for “Mom” in middle of Speech

Greg Gutfeld14 hours ago

[VIDEO] Greg Gutfeld can’t ‘stomach the crying’ from Jan. 6 commission members

Nancy Pelosi14 hours ago

[VIDEO] Lauren Boebert Lambasts Pelosi’s Actions As Speaker In Fiery House Floor Speech

Democrats2 days ago

[VIDEO] ‘The Five’ rips Texas Democrats begging for care packages

California2 days ago

[VIDEO] California Will Require Vaccinations Or Covid Tests For State Employees And Health Care Workers

Joe Biden2 days ago

[VIDEO] ‘Outnumbered’ reacts to Harris’ dipping poll numbers: ‘She’s not up to the task’

biden administration3 days ago

[VIDEO] Biden spends $2B to halt border wall construction: Senate report

Communist Dictatorship3 days ago

[VIDEO] Former President Trump Says US ‘Becoming A Communist Country,’ Jokes About Bernie Sanders

biden administration3 days ago

[VIDEO] Biden DOJ drops charges against five Chinese spies

Anthony Fauci3 days ago

[VIDEO] ‘He’s Not Going To Answer The Question’: GOP Senator Presses Fauci On COVID-19 Origin Theory

Antifa3 days ago

Watch: Antifa march and protest through Manhattan NYC. Harass and block streets

Democrats4 days ago

[VIDEO] FINALLY! MI Gov. Whitmer POWERLESS after Having Her Most Cherished Powers Stripped Away

biden foreign policy4 days ago

[VIDEO] Why is China buying US farmland? Morgan Ortagus explains

President Trump4 days ago

President Donald J. Trump Delivers Remarks at Turning Point Action

Trending

Copyright © 2021 Candace Owens Fans by TSD