Connect with us

Published

on

Advertisement



OK, so what might you do about that? Well, one thing you can do is to make it a rule. Ohio was maybe the first state to do that, and it happened pretty recently. In 2018, Ohio voters passed a [state] constitutional amendment creating a commission—a not-very-independent commission, it turns out—and written into those rules was the goal that the [partisan] share of seats should reflect the share of [statewide] votes. And as far as I know, that’s the first spelled-out instance of setting up proportionality as a goal.

For a mathematician like me, that’s really sensible: State your goals, then we can try to achieve them. But when your goals remain really vague, it’s very difficult to talk about why one might be better or fairer than the other.

When did you realize that your background in math had an application to gerrymandering?

I started working on this in 2016. My background in math is in geometry. And I thought, well, what if we tried to think about what it would mean to be “fair” on the district-drawing side?

I started with the intuition that the story is in the shapes, and that if we can just come up with the right shape metric, we’ll [solve it]. I went looking for the authoritative literature on all these “compactness” metrics that would tell the right story, and to my surprise, there was really classical math and ancient, pre-classical math, but there didn’t seem to be any kind of post-1900 mathematics in the mix.

The geometry of discrete spaces has really exploded in richness and depth in the last 100 years, but I wasn’t seeing a lot of those ideas in the mix. And it struck me — as many others have certaily realized before — that districting is really a discrete problem: There’s a finite number of people, and we have these geographic chunks that tell us where they are. So basically, I came to this thinking, “Oh, I bet there’s something that could be usefully done here.” And it has bloomed into a full-time research program.

One thing we’re going to deal with this redistricting cycle that we haven’t seen in the past is this new “differential privacy” approach by the Census, that actually changes the underlying data. Can you walk me through that, and how that will affect redistricting?

Yes. So, the Census Bureau has taken it upon themselves to do something cutting-edge—which always makes people nervous. In this case, they have “microdata”—the responses to all the census forms in, effectively, a giant table, with all the answers from every single person included in the enumeration. The bureau doesn’t release all of that information publicly. Instead, it aggregates it up: Census blocks or block groups will have maybe hundreds or a few thousand people in them, and you’ll get aggregate

Advertisement
statistics rather than individual people’s responses—so there will be a little chunk of a map, and you’ll know how many people live there and what their responses were, in aggregate.

The threat is now this: If you have enough of these aggregate statistics, you can throw them into a computer and actually reproduce the input table that made the aggregate statistics. Risk number one is that you can recover the person-level data. And risk number two, which is really interesting, is that if you pair it with easily available commercial data—like from Facebook—you could work out for quite a few of those people what their names and addresses and phone numbers are.

All this computing power being brought to bear on elections is generally pretty healthy and pro-democratic—people are coming up with ideas about making better systems and outcomes. But bad actors are also empowered by computing. That’s the risk—and it’s an interesting one. Under Title 13 of the U.S. Code, the Census Bureau is obligated to protect privacy. Does that include protecting people from these “reconstruction and reidentification” attacks, where you might have to use third-party data to do it? The Bureau has decided that the answer is yes.

So, they took this idea called “differential privacy,” which was created by Cynthia Dwork and her colleagues in computer science. And the idea is: What if you could, in a really controlled way, add random noise to all your numbers so that you’d be off a little bit here and there, but by the time you added it up, all those differences would cancel out and you’d get numbers that are very accurate at high levels, even if they’re very noisy at low levels?

It is a gorgeous idea. And the beauty of it is that you can do it in a really controlled way. The Census Bureau announced that they were going to do that, and chaos ensued. They’ve already been sued in a lawsuit led by Alabama.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Comments

Politics

DEAD ON ARRIVAL? GOP Blocks Dem Voting Bill with Filibuster, Leaders Say ‘Fight Not Over’

Published

on

By

Advertisement



ABRAMS CLAIM: Stacey Abrams Says She Was Nearly Blocked from Voting in Georgia Election

posted by Hannity Staff – 11.21.18

Democratic candidate in Georgia’s gubernatorial race Stacey Abrams claimed she was nearly blocked from voting this week; doubling-down on her previous comments that “voter suppression” led to an “unfair” midterm election.

Abrams was speaking with NPR when she stated an Election Day staffer attempted to stop her from casting her ballot; saying “The day I voted, I had to correct the poll worker who said I had filed for an absentee ballot.”

“I did it quietly. I didn’t turn it into a major conversation because, for me, it was about getting through the process,” she added. “But it was also emblematic to me of the privilege that I have.”

“I know the law … There are thousands, millions in Georgia who do not know what their rights are and therefore do not know that they shouldn’t have to wait in four-hour lines in the rain with their children. They shouldn’t have to worry about whether they will lose their jobs in order to exercise their democratic right to vote for their leader,” said Abrams

Read the full interview here.

ADD IT TO THE LIST: Hillary Blames Supreme Court Decision for 2016 Election Loss

posted by Hannity Staff – 9.17.19

Twice-failed presidential candidate Hillary Clinton continued her worldwide excuses tour this week; asserting a Supreme Court decision regarding the “Voting Rights Act” had a major impact in her 2016 loss to Donald Trump.

“Now, I was the first person who ran for president in more than 50 years without the protection of the Voting Rights Act. And let me just say, it makes a difference,” said Clinton at an event hosted by the American Federation of Teachers.

“The latest remarks were seemingly the first time she alleged a structural disadvantage created by the Supreme Court. In 2013, the Court drew Democrats’ ire when it struck down a portion of the Voting Rights Act, which was passed in 1965 as a way to secure voting rights for African Americans,” reports Fox News

Advertisement
.

“Voters faced intimidation and harassment that echoed some of the worst chapters in our nation’s history,” she said. “Voter ID requirements amounted to a modern-day poll tax. Voter ID requirements, which were literally made up for the purpose of preventing certain people from actually being able to cast a vote that would be counted. We saw fewer voting places, long lines, and malfunctioning equipment — again, in certain places.”

To date, Clinton has blamed her 2016 loss on the mainstream media, Facebook, Barack Obama, Bernie Sanders, the FBI, James Comey, misogyny, racism, local newspapers, Russia, and more.

Read the full report at Fox News.



Advertisement
Continue Reading

Crime

Joe Biden: “Police Chief Murray…Excuse Me, Police Chief Mary, Police Chief Murphy Paul”

Published

on

By

Advertisement

President Joe Biden said, “Police Chief Murray…excuse me, Police Chief Mary, Police Chief Murphy Paul,” during remarks he delivered at the White House on guns and the rise in crime on 6/23/2021.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Critical Race Theory

General’s response to Matt Gaetz leaves him shaking his head

Published

on

By

Advertisement

The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, Gen. Mark Milley, says he wants to know what caused the January 6th insurrection and fired back at Rep. Matt Gaetz’s (R-FL) question about critical race theory.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Politics34 mins ago

DEAD ON ARRIVAL? GOP Blocks Dem Voting Bill with Filibuster, Leaders Say ‘Fight Not Over’

Activist6 hours ago

Rose McGowan makes ‘big’ announcement on ‘Tucker Carlson Tonight’

arrestement6 hours ago

Parent arrested during school board meeting ‘chaos’ speaks out on ‘Tucker’

Immigration6 hours ago

Biden sent letter to Border Patrol chief telling him to relocate, retire or resign

Democrats6 hours ago

Jim Jordan Quotes Nadler’s Support Of Trump Facebook Ban, Doubts Dem Commitment To Combat Censorship

Crime6 hours ago

Joe Biden: “Police Chief Murray…Excuse Me, Police Chief Mary, Police Chief Murphy Paul”

Critical Race Theory6 hours ago

General’s response to Matt Gaetz leaves him shaking his head

Dinesh D’Souza8 hours ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene: Even Biden’s INFRASTRUCUTRE BILL Demeans Women Part 2– Interview Dinesh D’Souza

Dinesh D'Souza8 hours ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene: What Dems Won’t Tell You About Jan. 6 and Voter Integrity Part 1 – Interview Dinesh D’Souza

Andy Ngo9 hours ago

WATCH: Is this the ‘white supremacy Joe Biden has been talking about?’ Andy Ngo reveals Antifa demographics

Politics11 hours ago

New Jersey lawmakers advance $46.4B budget minutes after making it public

Politics12 hours ago

Harvard won’t host joint campaign managers event with Trump aides

Donald Trump13 hours ago

Kamala Harris Scrambles to Visit Border Before Donald Trump

biden administration14 hours ago

Biden Administration Asks Americans to Report ‘Potentially’ Radicalized Friends and Family

MAXINE WATERS15 hours ago

VIDEO – Maxine Waters: ‘I’m Told’ Organizing for January 6 Riot Took Place in the Trump Campaign

Politics2 weeks ago

No Masks, No Distancing – The Disgraceful Covid Hypocrisy of the G7 Elite

biden administration2 months ago

VIDEO: It’s ‘not a great time’ for America to have a ‘weak’ president: Andrew Bolt

Capitol Hill3 months ago

FIRST PHOTOS — Capitol Hill Killer is Black Muslim… Louis Farrakhan Supporter… Identified as 25 Year-Old Noah Green…

Nancy Pelosi3 months ago

VIDEO: FAIL: Nancy Pelosi’s Effort to Change GOP House Seat Blows Up In Her Face

2020 Election3 weeks ago

Sidney Powell’s bold prediction…

Candace Owens1 month ago

VIDEO: “No Escape For Pelosi, Jail Is Sure” Candace Owens Destroys Nancy Pelosi……

President Trump6 days ago

Trump announces brand new 2,000-mile long luxury hotel at Southern Border…

Whistle Blower1 week ago

Reporter Releases Undercover Video EXPOSING Media Bosses

Daunte Wright2 months ago

MSM will never show you this… Video of Daunte Wright waving around his gun…

Chicago2 days ago

HORROR In Chicago: Couple Pulled from Their Car and Shot Point Blank

Facebook3 months ago

Facebook removes Trump interview where he signals he will run for President in 2024…

Developing Story1 day ago

Arizona’s Katie Hobbs Suffers COMPLETE Meltdown on CNN – The Truth Is Coming

president biden1 week ago

‘Concerns’ for Joe Biden’s ‘mental capacity’ raised amid gaffes at G7

Border Patrol3 months ago

6 month-old baby tossed into Rio Grande by Joe Biden’s border smugglers…

Candace Owens Show2 months ago

Special Interview Episode 8 – The Road Ahead With President Donald J. Trump

Activist6 hours ago

Rose McGowan makes ‘big’ announcement on ‘Tucker Carlson Tonight’

arrestement6 hours ago

Parent arrested during school board meeting ‘chaos’ speaks out on ‘Tucker’

Immigration6 hours ago

Biden sent letter to Border Patrol chief telling him to relocate, retire or resign

Democrats6 hours ago

Jim Jordan Quotes Nadler’s Support Of Trump Facebook Ban, Doubts Dem Commitment To Combat Censorship

Crime6 hours ago

Joe Biden: “Police Chief Murray…Excuse Me, Police Chief Mary, Police Chief Murphy Paul”

Critical Race Theory6 hours ago

General’s response to Matt Gaetz leaves him shaking his head

Dinesh D’Souza8 hours ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene: Even Biden’s INFRASTRUCUTRE BILL Demeans Women Part 2– Interview Dinesh D’Souza

Dinesh D'Souza8 hours ago

Marjorie Taylor Greene: What Dems Won’t Tell You About Jan. 6 and Voter Integrity Part 1 – Interview Dinesh D’Souza

Andy Ngo9 hours ago

WATCH: Is this the ‘white supremacy Joe Biden has been talking about?’ Andy Ngo reveals Antifa demographics

Donald Trump1 day ago

Rob Schmitt: President Trump Says He’s Going After Mitch McConnell

Developing Story1 day ago

Arizona’s Katie Hobbs Suffers COMPLETE Meltdown on CNN – The Truth Is Coming

Critical Race Theory1 day ago

Arrests made after school board meeting on critical race theory got physical

Climate1 day ago

Tucker: Brace yourselves, climate lockdowns are coming

Breaking news1 day ago

Tucker roasts Eric Swalwell’s latest job listing

coronavirus1 day ago

‘I’ve Never Seen A Situation Like This’: Jim Jordan Questions Powell Over Enhanced Unemployment

Trending

Copyright © 2021 Candace Owens Fans by TSD